• Member Login
  • Contact
Menu
  • Member Login
  • Contact
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on email
Search
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on email
  • Member Login
  • Contact
Menu
  • Member Login
  • Contact
Search
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on email
Search
  • Home
  • News
    • News
    • The GYA Blog
    • GYA in the Media
    • COVID-19 Initiatives
  • Members
    • GYA Members
    • GYA Alumni
    • Recent Member Publications
    • Being a GYA Member
    • Call for New Members
    • Membership Map
    • Information for Alumni
  • Activities
    • Activties of the GYA
    • — Science & Society
    • — Research Environment
    • — Science Education & Outreach
    • — GYA & the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals
    • View all Activities
  • Events
    • Events
    • Annual General Meetings
  • Young Academies
    • National Young Academies
    • Establishing a Young Academy
    • Regional and global Young Academy meetings
    • Joint Young Academy Activities
  • Publications
    • Publications
    • Statements
    • GYA Podcast
    • Subscribe to the GYA Newsletter
    • Newsletter Archive
  • Resources
    • Resources
    • Opportunities
    • Science Advice Resource Centre
  • About
    • GYA in Brief
    • Constitution
    • Governance
    • Committees
    • Advisory Board
    • Host Academy
    • Partners
    • Team
    • Donate
    • Contact
Menu
  • Home
  • News
    • News
    • The GYA Blog
    • GYA in the Media
    • COVID-19 Initiatives
  • Members
    • GYA Members
    • GYA Alumni
    • Recent Member Publications
    • Being a GYA Member
    • Call for New Members
    • Membership Map
    • Information for Alumni
  • Activities
    • Activties of the GYA
    • — Science & Society
    • — Research Environment
    • — Science Education & Outreach
    • — GYA & the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals
    • View all Activities
  • Events
    • Events
    • Annual General Meetings
  • Young Academies
    • National Young Academies
    • Establishing a Young Academy
    • Regional and global Young Academy meetings
    • Joint Young Academy Activities
  • Publications
    • Publications
    • Statements
    • GYA Podcast
    • Subscribe to the GYA Newsletter
    • Newsletter Archive
  • Resources
    • Resources
    • Opportunities
    • Science Advice Resource Centre
  • About
    • GYA in Brief
    • Constitution
    • Governance
    • Committees
    • Advisory Board
    • Host Academy
    • Partners
    • Team
    • Donate
    • Contact
  • Home
  • News
    • News
    • The GYA Blog
    • GYA in the Media
    • COVID-19 Initiatives
  • Members
    • GYA Members
    • GYA Alumni
    • Recent Member Publications
    • Being a GYA Member
    • Call for New Members
    • Membership Map
    • Information for Alumni
  • Activities
    • Activties of the GYA
    • — Science & Society
    • — Research Environment
    • — Science Education & Outreach
    • — GYA & the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals
    • View all Activities
  • Events
    • Events
    • Annual General Meetings
  • Young Academies
    • National Young Academies
    • Establishing a Young Academy
    • Regional and global Young Academy meetings
    • Joint Young Academy Activities
  • Publications
    • Publications
    • Statements
    • GYA Podcast
    • Subscribe to the GYA Newsletter
    • Newsletter Archive
  • Resources
    • Resources
    • Opportunities
    • Science Advice Resource Centre
  • About
    • GYA in Brief
    • Constitution
    • Governance
    • Committees
    • Advisory Board
    • Host Academy
    • Partners
    • Team
    • Donate
    • Contact
Menu
  • Home
  • News
    • News
    • The GYA Blog
    • GYA in the Media
    • COVID-19 Initiatives
  • Members
    • GYA Members
    • GYA Alumni
    • Recent Member Publications
    • Being a GYA Member
    • Call for New Members
    • Membership Map
    • Information for Alumni
  • Activities
    • Activties of the GYA
    • — Science & Society
    • — Research Environment
    • — Science Education & Outreach
    • — GYA & the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals
    • View all Activities
  • Events
    • Events
    • Annual General Meetings
  • Young Academies
    • National Young Academies
    • Establishing a Young Academy
    • Regional and global Young Academy meetings
    • Joint Young Academy Activities
  • Publications
    • Publications
    • Statements
    • GYA Podcast
    • Subscribe to the GYA Newsletter
    • Newsletter Archive
  • Resources
    • Resources
    • Opportunities
    • Science Advice Resource Centre
  • About
    • GYA in Brief
    • Constitution
    • Governance
    • Committees
    • Advisory Board
    • Host Academy
    • Partners
    • Team
    • Donate
    • Contact

News of the Global Young Academy

  • GYA Home
  • News
  • Workshop on Research Assessment with ALLEA - Report published

Workshop on Research Assessment with ALLEA – Report published

In November 2020, GYA alumni Boon Han Lim (Tunku Abdul Rahman University, Malaysia) and Martin Dominik (University of St Andrews, UK) as members of the GYA working group on Scientific Excellence, together with ALLEA, jointly organised an online workshop entitled “Research assessments that promote scholarly progress and reinforce the contract with society”.

A workshop report has now been published: LINK

You can watch the original event here:

YouTube

By loading the video, you agree to YouTube’s privacy policy.
Learn more

Load video

The event raised key questions about the purpose and goals of research assessments. A presentation by Ellen Hazelkorn (BH Associates educational consultants) set the scene, in which she outlined the role of science, its framing by an accountability agenda, competitiveness pressure vs enhancing capacity, rising inequalities, international collaboration, science literacy, and the impact on trust, arguing the case for a holistic engagement between universities and society. This was followed by brief interventions from Kostas Glinos (European Commission), Michael Hill (DORA Steering Committee) and GYA alumnus Martin Dominik.

Kostas emphasised that science must not be considered elitist and needs to be responsible to society. Michael mentioned that too many publications of low quality pose a problem, we face a gap in adequately communicating science, and that researchers should take back control through the Open Science movement, also addressing unhealthy hierarchic structures. Martin raised various points such as diversity being a key asset of our society, the need to look at research as process, the role of interactions between researchers and specific context, responsible management and empowered actors, ethical leadership and trust, as well as the meaninglessness of universal rankings and the harmfulness of ill-conceived assessment, and finally stressed that equitable sharing of benefits is a major challenge for an open science global ecosystem.

In a subsequent discussion round on audience questions, moderated by Roger Pfister (ALLEA), it was moreover brought up that, as reflected in the Hong Kong Principles, rigour and integrity are decisive and critical qualities defining the value of research, while societal relevance stretches beyond addressing immediate needs given that innovation frequently stems from unexpected outcomes. Moreover, evaluation pressure and driving by incentives can be counterproductive, whereas initiative needs support.

The debate provided much food for thought on framing the issue, but it requires to be followed up with efforts on developing concrete policies and putting them into place.

Workshop report: LINK

 

Viewing News Article

  • Posted in News
  • on 22 July 2021
  • by Anna-Maria Gramatté
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email
Share on print

Read more
GYA members at the United Nations Science Summit 77
13 October 2022
GYA members at the United Nations Science Summit 77
GYA Statement about violence in Iran
12 October 2022
GYA Statement about violence in Iran
Back to basics: fundamental research report launch
12 October 2022
Back to basics: fundamental research report launch
Introducing the Science Advice Resource Centre
25 April 2022
Introducing the Science Advice Resource Centre

PrevPreviousGYA member Mai Tolba featured in “The Next Big Thing” video series
NextCall for Virtual YSAP Missions 2021Next

Global Young Academy

GYA Home
News
  • News
  • The GYA Blog
  • GYA in the Media
  • COVID-19 Initiatives
Members
  • Members
  • Alumni
  • Recent Member Publications
  • Being a GYA member
  • Call for Members
  • Membership Map
  • Information for Alumni
Activities
  • Activities of the GYA
  • Science & Society
  • Research Environment
  • Science Education & Outreach
  • GYA & The United Nations Sustainable Development Goals
  • View all Activities
Events
  • Events Overview
  • Annual General Meetings
 
Young Academies
  • National Young Academies
  • Establishing a Young Academy
  • Regional and global Young Academy meetings
  • Joint Young Academies Activities
Publications
  • Publications
  • Statements
  • GYA Podcast
  • Subscribe to our Newsletter
  • Newsletter Archive
Resources
  • Science Advice Resource Center
  • Opportunities
About Us
  • GYA in Brief
  • Constitution
  • Governance
  • Committees
  • Advisory Board
  • Host Academy
  • Partners
  • Team
  • Donate
  • Contact
  • Member Login
  • Jobs & Calls for Bids
  • Legal notice
  • Privacy Policy

The GYA in your inbox, subscribe to our newsletter now.

  • Legal notice
  • Privacy Policy
Menu
  • Legal notice
  • Privacy Policy

© 2023 Global Young Academy